From a fellow atheist. But, he's not that enamored of the new atheists' thoughts on religion, especially what the effects of religion are on society. And also some of their very illiberal thoughts on what to do with kids that are raised in religious homes.
To be fair the reviewer is a conservative, and for the most part, even atheist conservatives want religion in society. Churchill, who was for all intensive purposes an atheist, said he was"a buttress of the Church of England supporting it from the outside".
UPDATE: Reply from a sympathetic fellow Atheist/Mysterian/conservative. Not entirely convinced. And just thoughts on mysterianism and "unwilling unbelievers in general.